Solar Power World

  • Home
  • Top Solar Contractors
  • Solar+Storage
  • Articles
    • Most Recent Posts
    • News
      • Latest News Items
      • Solar tariffs
      • COVID-19 News
    • Featured
      • Latest Feature Stories
      • Contractors Corner
      • Installation Practices
      • Trends in Solar
      • Folsom Labs Solar Boot-Up
      • The Solar Explorer
  • Products
    • 2020 Top Products
    • Batteries and Storage
    • Inverters
      • Manufacturing Locations
    • Racking and Mounting
    • Software
    • Solar Panels
      • Manufacturing Locations
  • Leadership
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners
    • 2018 Winners
  • Subscribe
  • Resources
    • About SPW
    • Digital Issues
    • Event Coverage
    • Podcasts
    • Product Databases
      • Solar Inverter Models
      • Solar Panel Models
      • Solar Racking Models
      • Battery Storage Models
    • Product Manufacturing Locations
      • Global Inverter Manufacturing Locations
      • Global Solar Panel Manufacturing Locations
    • Suppliers
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • COVID-19 NEWS

The shape of shade: Understanding the relationship between an obstruction’s height vs. distance

By Paul Grana | December 5, 2018

Share

Pop quiz: say you have a tree that is shading your array—then you make it 20 ft taller, while also moving it 20 ft farther from the roof. Are you better or worse off? It turns out that the shade losses will usually drop—and this phenomenon is one of the most commonly misunderstood factors that we hear from designers.

Understanding the shape of shade

Many people think the two trees will cast equal shade on the array. However, the impact of changing an obstruction’s height and/or distance vary greatly based on the relative location of the object versus the array. As can be seen in Figure 1, adding distance between the tree and the array will reduce the shade loss more than reducing the height would. For example, note that when a tree’s height grows from 50 ft to 70 ft, the shade impact can be more than offset if the tree is just 10 ft farther away from the solar array.

Figure 1: Shade loss values based on height of object and distance from array

Said differently, a taller tree that is farther away from the array creates less shade than a shorter tree that is closer to the array. You might have a really scary looking tree that is 100-ft tall, but if it is 70 ft from the array, the shade losses can be negligible.

To understand why this is the case, it helps to look at the shade loss from an object in a more abstract sense. Let’s examine what happens when we simulate a large 100-ft tower surrounded by modules on all sides. Only the modules closest to the tower receive significant shade loss (a few with shade losses above 50%). By the time you are 30 ft from the tower (about six rows of modules) the shading losses drop to under 10%.

Figure 2: 10% shade threshold next to 100-ft tower

Modules farther than 30-ft away are only impacted slightly by the tower, with shade losses on the order of 1 to 4%.

Figure 3: Shaded modules at 50% shading, 10% shading and 1.7% shading from 100-ft obstruction

In essence, the shade loss from an object nearly resembles a 1/x curve: it’s very high close to the object, but falls quickly before flattening out at low values.

Figure 4: Curve showing y=1/x

Real-world manifestation

This concept of relative shade loss comes up all the time with HelioScope users. Most commonly, somebody will design a system near a tree that is 80 100-ft tall. Yet the shade losses from the tree will only be 2 to 3%, sometimes even less. As we troubleshoot, it turns out that the imposing tree is also 100 ft away from the array—and that distance effectively neutralizes the height. An oak in the neighbor’s property is less daunting than a nearby sapling.

Ultimately, the main takeaway here is that our intuition is often wrong with respect to how much shade we should expect from an obstruction. Based on our conversations, it seems like people often focus entirely on the height of the tree or building, and have difficulty factoring in how far away it is. As a result, we are often more hesitant to design around tall obstructions – but if you just run the analysis, you might be surprised at how modest the shade impact is.

About The Author

Paul Grana

Paul Grana is the co-founder of Folsom Labs, where he leads sales and marketing, where he has helped to grow the company to thousands of installers in over 70 countries. He also founded the S3 Solar Software Summit, which brings together the industry’s leading software vendors and buyers each year. He previously worked at Abound Solar, and led product management and technical marketing with Tigo Energy. Paul holds a BS in Mathematics and Economics from the University of Chicago, and an MBA from Harvard Business School.

Comments

  1. Leslie says

    May 23, 2019 at 6:50 pm

    Is it okay to have a clump of trees on the north side of the array when it is facing south? They are evergreens – fir and pine, and the outer branches would only be about 5 feet away from it. Thanks.

    Reply
  2. Janet B says

    April 8, 2019 at 8:22 pm

    Thanks for the article. I live in Nevada, I have been searching for the following information for 2 weeks, I just keep getting solar sales when googling my questions. If anyone can help, I’d appreciate any information.
    Where specifically do I find the laws (state/federal) regarding screening ground mount solar panels with trees? My neighbor just put up 42 ground mount panels and we want to require/request they screen with trees to prevent the glare, not to mention the eyesore of our once beautiful view. I’ve been told by our HOA they can’t do trees because they will lose more than 10% of their solar. I’d like to see this law in writing but can’t find. Additionally the solar company was the group that determined trees won’t work and I was under the impression a non biased professional needs to make this determination using specific calculations and write up a report? If so, do neighbors have the right to ask to see said report, is it recorded as a public document?
    I also “think” my HOA is correct they can not deny solar no matter the size, because it’s a federal law.
    Any help would be very much appreciated.
    Thanks

    Reply
    • Kelly Pickerel says

      April 9, 2019 at 7:48 am

      Trees can put shadows on solar panels, limiting their production. So your HOA is correct. Neighbor requests cannot limit the original solar production. Search for solar access laws or solar easements in Nevada. Here’s a little more information: https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2018/08/solar-hoa/

      Reply
  3. Socal says

    March 9, 2019 at 9:32 am

    Hello… I recently found out NREL’s Solar Advisor Model (SAM) is now open source. There are several versions available but I can’t find an Excel VBA version. I’ve built multiple VBA solar models over the years based on PVFORM and PV Watts. These models aren’t meant to be commercial grade but they’re good basic platforms. Does anyone know of a solar forum with an active solar modeling community?

    Reply
  4. Nsikan Ikpe says

    December 16, 2018 at 11:15 pm

    Hello!
    I am Research student working on the “failure mechanism of solar panels.” I would be glad if you can help with useful information on the causes of failures especially in solar street light application.

    Reply
  5. Taran King says

    December 14, 2018 at 8:35 am

    Paul,

    Great article. I was wondering how that relationship may change in the events of a wider obstruction, for example, a tree line or another building. Would the relationship then become more linear?

    Reply
  6. Ilze Greene says

    December 6, 2018 at 12:56 pm

    Paul,

    As a solar lighting company, we’re getting into more and more partially shaded environments. We do have someone doing shade analysis internally but I love the user friendly statement “…when a tree’s height grows from 50 ft to 70 ft, the shade impact can be more than offset if the tree is just 10 ft farther away from the solar array.”

    Very helpful for communicating with customers. I’ll be sharing your article with our followers.

    Reply
    • Paul Grana says

      December 11, 2018 at 12:55 am

      Great to hear Ilze, thanks!

      Reply

Tell Us What You Think! Cancel reply

Related Articles Read More >

Sungrow energy storage systems going in at 100-MW battery project in Texas
Enphase energy storage systems now compatible with existing M-Series microinverters
New entrants bring flexibility in rapid shutdown device choice
2021 Trends in Solar
An installation boom is coming to the Northeast and its temperamental soil conditions
2021 Trends in Solar

Stay Informed With Great Solar Power Content

Videos Podcasts Webinars Whitepapers

SPW Digital Editions

Solar Power World Digital EditionBrowse the current issue and archived issues of Solar Power World in an easy-to-use, high-quality format. Bookmark, share and interact with the leading solar construction magazine today.

Solar Policy Snapshot

Solar policy differs across state lines and regions. Click to see our monthly roundup of recent legislation and research throughout the country.

Read More >

Popular Posts See More >

Solar investment tax credit extended at 26% for two additional years
The winners and losers in U.S. solar manufacturing in 2020
The changing state of retiring solar panels
Think before trashing: The second-hand solar market is booming
Tweets by @SolarPowerWorld
Solar Power World
  • Top Solar Contractors
  • Solar Articles
  • Top Products
  • Leadership
  • WTWH Media
  • About/Contact Us
  • Advertising
  • Subscribe
  • Windpower Engineering & Development

Copyright © 2021 WTWH Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Site Map | Privacy Policy | RSS

Search Solar Power World

  • Home
  • Top Solar Contractors
  • Solar+Storage
  • Articles
    • Most Recent Posts
    • News
      • Latest News Items
      • Solar tariffs
      • COVID-19 News
    • Featured
      • Latest Feature Stories
      • Contractors Corner
      • Installation Practices
      • Trends in Solar
      • Folsom Labs Solar Boot-Up
      • The Solar Explorer
  • Products
    • 2020 Top Products
    • Batteries and Storage
    • Inverters
      • Manufacturing Locations
    • Racking and Mounting
    • Software
    • Solar Panels
      • Manufacturing Locations
  • Leadership
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners
    • 2018 Winners
  • Subscribe
  • Resources
    • About SPW
    • Digital Issues
    • Event Coverage
    • Podcasts
    • Product Databases
      • Solar Inverter Models
      • Solar Panel Models
      • Solar Racking Models
      • Battery Storage Models
    • Product Manufacturing Locations
      • Global Inverter Manufacturing Locations
      • Global Solar Panel Manufacturing Locations
    • Suppliers
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • COVID-19 NEWS